How To Deal With “Constructive” Criticism


An excerpt from the forthcoming book Let Me Out (Unlock your creative mind and bring your ideas to life)

“A while back I got a letter from a woman who sent an early draft of a book of poetry to a friend and got a “lukewarm” response. Now, she feels like her poems are no good. Here’s what I wrote in response:

Dear L.,

I really wish I could have shared what I’m going to say to you before you let your friend read the manuscript. But since you already have, consider it as my Grandma Rose used to say in Yiddish, “b’sheret”—meant to be.

Here’s the cold truth about friendships: Oftentimes people whom we consider to be our good friends may be harshly critical of things we are passionate about. I call these people External Deflators (or EDs). EDs’ negative tendencies (just like Marv’s team of internal Deflators) make ideas that haven’t had a chance to fully form extremely susceptible to negative feedback. EDs are functionally fixed and as such they’re bringing Stuck- inking to the table when they should be bringing Kid-thinking.

I think of my own work in its early stages as tender shoots that can be easily uprooted and destroyed. Knowing this, I’m always very judicious about who I’ll let see early drafts of things I create. I’m not looking for people to fawn over the ideas at this early stage, but I am looking for guidance and support. As such, I’m selective in presenting these early iterations only to people who are familiar with the process of inventing things, people who through their own experience with innovation are knowledgeable and sensitive about the delicate nature of early work.

I’m not only lucky to have such people in my life, I’ve actively sought them out over the years as kindred spirits and I’ve cultivated friendships based on the knowledge that we offer one another support, inspiration, and guidance as opposed to so-called “constructive criticism,” which in many cases feels like a thinly veiled means of throwing cold water on a project.
I’m not a cynic. I believe most people’s motives are good. It’s just that EDs are not empathetic, so they fail to realize the damage they’re causing. They don’t try to problem solve (what an innovator does); they problem-identify and think the idea lacks merit because of the problem’s existence.

All creation is a process of creating order and solutions out of chaos and problems. It’s a process of motion—going from one place to another. Saying something is bad completely disregards how close to great it might actually be.
So L., it’s impossible for me to determine just how your friend’s comments are intended and what your level of sensitivity to the comments might actually be, though my suspicion is aroused whenever I see someone go away “deflated” as opposed to strengthened after an encounter.

The questions to ask yourself are these: Were you uplifted by the conversation with your friend (even if it included advice and opinions that might differ from your own), or were you made to feel humiliated and that your aspirations had no merit? It’s vital that you take your creative ideas into the world. Yet, you must always exercise the appropriate caution in not bringing things that are still in process to an External Deflator.”

For more info and to pre-order check out:


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s